News & Insights

The Scope of Paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 of the Building Safety Act 2022 Applies to Unsafe Cladding Where There is No Relevant Defect

  • Posted on

In a key building safety decision handed down this week, the Court of Appeal confirms that the protection for qualifying leaseholders in paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 to the Building Safety Act 2022 (BSA) is not limited to "relevant defects".

 

Background
Centre Point House (CPH) is a six-storey podium of 36 duplex flats above retail units, part of the 1960s Centre Point development in London. The timber-framed glazed façade was inherently defective: water ingress has caused rot, and one casement panel had already fallen. The freeholders (Almacantar Centre Point Nominees No. 1 & No. 2) proposed a steel stick curtain wall system fixed to the concrete frame and superimposed on the existing timbers, at an expected cost of over £12 million. The façade experts agreed this was the best, and realistically the only, solution.
In January 2023, the landlords applied to the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) under s.27A of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985. The FTT held that the works fell within the repairing covenants. However, it held that paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 to the BSA protected tenants with “qualifying leases”, so only tenants without qualifying leases would pay. The Upper Tribunal (UT) dismissed the landlords’ subsequent appeal in September 2025.

The Legal Challenge
Paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 of the BSA provides that no service charge is payable under a qualifying lease for “cladding remediation”: the removal or replacement of any part of a cladding system that forms the outer wall of an external wall system and is unsafe. The Appellant landlords appealed on five main grounds:
1. Paragraph 8 applies only to “relevant defects”, which must arise from works within the 30 years before 28 June 2022. CPH pre-dated that period.
2. That the façade was not “cladding”.
3. The scheme did not involve removing or replacing part of a cladding system.
4. Any cladding system was the whole external wall, not the “outer wall of an external wall system”.
5. “Unsafe” means combustible or a fire-spread risk, not structural danger.

The Decision
The Court of Appeal (Newey and Fancourt LJJ, with Miles LJ) agreed unanimously and dismissed the appeal. In analysing the judgment against each of the main arguments, the reasoning was as follows:

  •  Ground 1.
    Paragraph 8 does not mention “relevant defects”, unlike paragraphs 2–7 and 9, and that contrast was “crucial”. Paragraph 8(2)(b) separately requires the cladding to be “unsafe”, and paragraph 10(2) refers to a “thing” rather than a defect. Sections 116 and 122 are introductory and incomplete, not limiting. Paragraph 8 can therefore apply to pre-1992 defects.
  •  Grounds 2 and 3.
    A key point to note is that the failure of the appeal on these grounds turned on a distinction between questions of law and questions of fact. Whether something is categorised as “cladding” or a “cladding system” was a question of fact for the specialist FTT. The appellants did not challenge the FTT’s factual findings and there was no suggestion that no reasonable tribunal could have reached its conclusion. The FTT found that the timber frame, glazing, spandrels, insulation and fixings formed the cladding system, and that much of it would be removed and replaced.
  • Ground 4.
    The FTT found that the cladding system was only the outer part of a wider external wall system, (which included the dwarf walls, concrete structure and party walls) and this was not a case where the two were the same thing. The court left open the question whether a cladding system that constitutes the entire external wall can fall within paragraph 8.
    Ground 5.
    The Appeal on Ground 5 also failed. “Unsafe”was deemed to carry “an ordinary” meaning that was not confined solely to fire risk. The FTT’s finding that the façade was dangerous was therefore sufficient to satisfy paragraph 8(2)(b).

Implications
The Court of Appeal’s guidance on the scope of paragraph 8 is significant. The decision confirms, the protection against cladding remediation costs can apply to older buildings, and to defects outside the 30-year window, where a qualifying lease exists. Landlords cannot assume that falling outside the “relevant defect” definition automatically preserves service charge recovery.
In addition to the difficulty of challenging factual questions, the decision also indicates that “Unsafe” has a broad meaning. Structural or other danger, not just fire risk, can engage paragraph 8, and that repair schemes need careful scrutiny. It would be advisable to identify qualifying leases early, and assess whether proposed works constitute “cladding remediation” within paragraph 8 before issuing demands, and avoid the assumption that repairing covenants alone justify recovery.

    Get in touch

    Please fill in the form and we’ll get back to you as soon as we can.






    I accept that my data will be held for the purpose of my enquiry in accordance with JB Leitch Privacy Policy

    Written by Katie Edwards

    Author